On The Main Blog

Creative Minority Reader

Michael Sean Winters' Whopper

You know. I'm almost starting to get the idea that Catholic writer Michael Sean Winters may be intellectually dishonest. I'm not saying he is. I'm just saying that it almost seems like it sometimes. Like...um...today for example. The Catholic Key discusses what he calls Winters' latest "whopper."

“The Hyde Amendment is nearly as settled law as is Roe,” Winters writes today over at NCR. You can go there to see the full context of the remark. I’m not interested in entering the specific argument over a public option. Rather, I’d like to point out that in the service of his political policy preferences Winters is capable of the most enormous whopper.

Here is what I’m certain Mr. Winters knows about the relative weight of Hyde versus Roe.

Roe v Wade is a Supreme Court decision. It supersedes and invalidates all existing or future democratically or legislatively enacted laws which the Court itself deems in conflict with it.
Continue reading>>>

Your Ad Here

2 comments:

Rick said...

I agree about the intellectual dishonesty or he loves the Democrats positions so much that he adjusts reality to it. And that makes him foolish.

Anonymous said...

Just keep in mind that pro-life dem.s don't buy it (officially).


Popular Posts